Date of Award

7-3-2026

Thesis Type

PhD

Document Type

Thesis

Degree Name

Doctor of Philosophy (Medical Science)

Divisions

Faculty of Dentistry

Department

Department of Orthodontics, Paediatric and Special Care Dentistry

Institution

Universiti Malaya

Abstract

Dental plaque accumulation and the development of white spot lesions (WSLs) remain significant challenges during fixed orthodontic treatment due to difficulties in maintaining optimal oral hygiene around orthodontic appliances. Conventional oral hygiene practices include toothbrushing with fluoridated toothpaste, and the use of interdental brushes and dental floss is widely recommended. However, plaque retention remains common and may lead to enamel demineralisation, with reported WSL incidence ranging from 20% to 50%. Water flossers (WF) have emerged as an alternative interdental cleaning method, demonstrating effectiveness in maintaining dental and gingival health. Nevertheless, evidence regarding their role in preventing WSLs among orthodontic patients remains limited. This study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of a water flosser compared with conventional interdental cleaning tools in plaque removal, prevention of white spot lesions, and maintenance of gingival health during fixed orthodontic treatment. The primary objectives were to compare plaque accumulation using the Orthodontic Plaque Index (OPI), enamel decalcification using the Enamel Decalcification Index , and gingival health using the Gingival Index (GI), while secondary objectives included assessing the correlation between plaque accumulation and enamel decalcification and evaluating patient perceptions of the two oral hygiene methods. This open-label, singlecentre, randomised clinical trial recruited 32 orthodontic patients according to predefined inclusion and exclusion criteria and allocated them using block randomisation to two groups: Group 1 (water flosser, WF; n = 16) and Group 2 (interdental brush and dental iv floss, ICT; n = 16). Participants received standardised oral hygiene instructions according to group allocation and were followed for 32 weeks, with regular clinical examinations and standardised photographic documentation. Plaque accumulation was assessed using OPI at 8 weeks (T₁), 16 weeks (T₂), 24 weeks (T₃), and 32 weeks (T₄). Enamel decalcification and gingival health were evaluated using EDI and GI at five time points from baseline (T₀, 0 week) to T₄. All participants completed the study with no dropouts. Both groups demonstrated a gradual reduction in plaque scores over time, with significantly lower OPI values observed in Group 2 at 8 and 24 weeks (p < 0.05). The incidence of enamel decalcification increased progressively in both groups, with no statistically significant intergroup differences at any time point (p > 0.05), while gingival health improved similarly in both groups. No strong or consistent correlation was observed between plaque accumulation and enamel decalcification. Patient satisfaction remained consistent in Group 1 but declined slightly in Group 2. In conclusion, both water flossers and interdental cleaning tools demonstrated comparable effectiveness in preventing white spot lesions over the 32-week period. However, interdental cleaning tools achieved significantly lower plaque levels at specific time points, while water flossers showed more consistent improvement in gingival health. These findings suggest that each method offers distinct clinical benefits, and their use may be guided by the specific oral hygiene needs of orthodontic patients.

Initial

khm

Additional Information

Thesis (PhD) – Faculty of Dentistry, Universiti Malaya, 2026.

Available for download on Monday, July 03, 2028

Share

COinS