Are we reusing heritage safely? Stakeholder perceptions and safety priorities in the adaptive reuse of Chinese architectural heritage

Document Type

Article

Publication Date

4-1-2026

Abstract

As more architectural heritage sites are repurposed to meet modern functional needs, safety—though increasingly recognized as vital to sustainable heritage management—often remains a secondary concern. This study proposes a stakeholder-centred framework to identify and assess key safety indicators in repurposed heritage buildings, using the UNESCO-listed villages of Xidi and Hongcun in China as case studies. An exploratory mixed methods was employed. In the first phase, template analysis and consensus-based focus group sessions were used to identify, refine, and prioritize safety indicators across five dimensions: Structural Integrity, Fire Protection, Usability, Environmental Preparedness, And Maintenance Systems. In the second phase, a survey of 426 stakeholders measured satisfaction levels with these indicators and identified areas for future improvement. The findings reveal a gap between perceived importance and actual performance, particularly in emergency preparedness, fire protection equipment, and internal infrastructure. This study contributes to heritage risk research by applying Protection Motivation Theory (PMT) to adaptive reuse and empirically validating a stakeholder-driven safety framework using Importance–Performance Analysis (IPA). It offers a diagnostic tool that connects cognitive risk appraisal with practical governance.

Keywords

Adaptive reuse, Architectural heritage, Safety assessment, Stakeholder perception, Sustainable heritage management

Publication Title

Environmental Impact Assessment Review

ISSN

0195-9255

DOI

10.1016/j.eiar.2025.108257

Volume

118

Publisher

Elsevier Inc.

Share

COinS