Perceived harmfulness of e-cigarettes and heated tobacco products compared to cigarettes: Findings from the 2020 ITC Malaysia survey

Document Type

Article

Publication Date

7-1-2026

Abstract

Introduction: Misperceptions about nicotine product harms may influence product use and switching behaviors. Methods: Data were from the 2020 International Tobacco Control (ITC) Malaysia Survey, a nationally representative survey of 1047 adults aged ≥ 18 who smoked cigarettes at least monthly and had smoked ≥ 100 cigarettes (n = 1047). Respondents reported awareness of HTPs and ECs and perceived harmfulness relative to cigarettes. For regression analyses, perceived harmfulness vs cigarettes were categorized as less harmful, equally/more harmful, or don’t know; for HTP-EC comparisons, categories were HTP more harmful, equally/EC more harmful, or don’t know. Results: Overall, 53.4% respondents had heard of HTPs, with lower awareness among women, ethnic minorities, and those with lower educational attainment. Among those aware of HTPs, 39.7% perceived HTPs as less harmful and 38.9% as equally harmful as cigarettes. Ethnic minority respondents were more likely to perceive HTPs as equally/more harmful than cigarettes or to report don’t know, while those with secondary or lower education had lower odds of reporting don’t know. Among adults aware of ECs, 46.4% perceived ECs as less harmful than cigarettes, while 29.7% and 14.1% perceived them as equally or more harmful. Respondent aged ≥ 40 had higher odds of perceiving ECs as equally/more harmful than cigarettes or reporting don’t know. When comparing HTPs and ECs directly, 49.5% perceived them as equally harmful and 25.3% perceived HTPs as more harmful than ECs, while respondents aged ≥ 40 were more likely to report don’t know. Conclusion: Perceptions of harm varied across products and sociodemographic groups, indicating gaps in understanding nicotine product harms.

Keywords

Cigarettes, E-cigarettes, Heated tobacco products, Malaysia, Perceived harmfulness

Publication Title

Drug and Alcohol Dependence

ISSN

0376-8716

DOI

10.1016/j.drugalcdep.2026.113179

Volume

284

Share

COinS