Impact of Virtual Reality and Haptic Simulators in Dental Education and Training Among Dental Students: An Umbrella Review
Document Type
Article
Publication Date
1-1-2026
Abstract
Objectives: To synthesise and critically appraise systematic reviews evaluating the impact of virtual reality (VR) and haptic simulators on dental students' learning outcomes in preclinical and clinical education. Methods: Three databases were searched from January 2011 to June 2025. Eligible evidence comprised only systematic reviews (with/without meta-analysis) published in English which focused on undergraduate or postgraduate dental students using VR, haptic, or integrated VR–haptic simulation for skills training. Two reviewers independently screened records, extracted data, appraised methodological quality using A MeaSurement Tool to Assess systematic Reviews 2 (AMSTAR 2), and calculated the Corrected Covered Area (CCA) to assess citation overlap. Results: Six systematic reviews met the inclusion criteria; one included a meta-analysis reporting a significant performance advantage after haptic-simulator training, albeit with very high heterogeneity (I2 = 92%). Across reviews, VR–haptic training was consistently associated with improved preclinical performance (accuracy, error reduction, efficiency) and greater learner confidence, with the strongest evidence in restorative dentistry and supportive signals in endodontics, implantology, periodontics, paediatric dentistry, radiology and oral & maxillofacial surgery. Methodological confidence was limited: AMSTAR 2 ratings were low to critically low. Overlap analysis indicated moderate redundancy (CCA = 6.05%), suggesting some recirculation of primary trials across reviews. Conclusions: VR and haptic simulators confer meaningful advantages for preclinical acquisition and learner confidence in dental education, but certainty is tempered by methodological weaknesses and substantial heterogeneity. Their optimal role is as high-fidelity adjuncts within blended curricula.
Keywords
dental education, haptic simulation, systematic review, umbrella review, virtual reality
Publication Title
European Journal of Dental Education
ISSN
1396-5883
DOI
10.1111/eje.70150
Recommended Citation
Luai, Amirul Faiz; Zawawi, Nur Dini Ahmad; Rusli, Fadhli; Lin, Galvin Sim Siang; Nagasawa, Masako; Rani, Haslina; Park, Young Seok; Dom, Tuti Ningseh Mohd; and Kadir, Rahimah Abdul, "Impact of Virtual Reality and Haptic Simulators in Dental Education and Training Among Dental Students: An Umbrella Review" (2026). Research Publications (2026 to 2030). 2094.
https://knova.um.edu.my/research_publications_2026_2030/2094
Publisher
John Wiley and Sons