“In the Black Abyss There Appeared a Single Eye”: The Gaze and Self-Fragmentation in The Lord of the Rings

Document Type

Article

Publication Date

1-1-2026

Abstract

While The Lord of the Rings has been examined through various critical perspectives, including Jungian individuation, such readings often assume Tolkien’s engagement with vision leads to revelation or self-knowledge. This study challenges that perspective, arguing that Tolkien portrays vision as epistemically unstable, aligning with modernist anxieties about perception, fragmented identity, and deferred meaning. Employing close reading, this study examines Galadriel’s Mirror through a Lacanian lens, focusing on méconnaissance, the gaze, and jouissance to demonstrate how vision in Tolkien’s work entraps rather than enlightens. Frodo’s and Sam’s encounters with the Mirror reveal an interpretative abyss where knowledge remains elusive. By reframing Tolkien’s treatment of vision through psychoanalysis and modernist literary discourse, this study situates his work within a broader critique of prophecy, perception, and the limits of knowledge, accentuating its engagement with the precarious nature of meaning and the instability of selfhood–an aspect often overlooked in Tolkien scholarship.

Publication Title

Critique Studies in Contemporary Fiction

ISSN

00111619

DOI

10.1080/00111619.2025.2482937

Volume

67

Issue

2

First Page

368

Last Page

377

Share

COinS