Comparative evaluation of seven precipitation products in rainfall estimation over tropical Peninsular Malaysia
Document Type
Article
Publication Date
2-1-2026
Abstract
Accurate quantification of rainfall is essential for climate assessments and disaster risk reduction. This study compares the performance of seven precipitation products in rainfall estimation against a dense rain gauge network over Peninsular Malaysia during 2014–2019. Assessments were conducted at daily and seasonal timescales using both continuous and categorical error metrics to examine spatiotemporal accuracy. The ability of each product to represent rainfall climatology, including the annual cycle and interannual extremes, was also investigated. In point-to-grid comparisons, MSWEP and IMERG exhibit good point-scale accuracy, though substantial spatial inconsistencies persist across all products. IMERG and CMORPH are the most skillful in replicating daily rainfall dynamics based on the modified Kling–Gupta efficiency and demonstrate more balanced categorical performance in detecting rain events. However, weak correlation remains a key limitation across all products. Spatiotemporal analysis reveals higher skills in wetter regions but lower skills in drier regions across all timescales, suggesting a magnitude-dependent error structure. Most products fail to replicate seasonal shifts in rainfall distribution, especially for lower and moderate intensity classes. While rainfall climatology is misrepresented in terms of magnitude, temporal variability is reasonably tracked. Overall, IMERG emerges as the best-performing product. The collective findings shed light on the reliability of precipitation products in estimating tropical rainfall for water resources management purposes. Future work should quantify uncertainty propagation in rainfall–runoff processes and characterize cross-correlation structures between rainfall and atmospheric drivers.
Keywords
Categorical metrics, Kling–Gupta efficiency, Reanalysis datasets, Satellite precipitation products, Tropical monsoon cycle, Uncertainty analysis
Publication Title
Stochastic Environmental Research and Risk Assessment
ISSN
1436-3240
DOI
10.1007/s00477-025-03166-y
Recommended Citation
Ng, Cia Yik; Othman, Faridah; Wan Jaafar, Wan Zurina; Lai, Sai Hin; Mei, Yiwen; Juneng, Liew; and Soo, Eugene Zhen Xiang, "Comparative evaluation of seven precipitation products in rainfall estimation over tropical Peninsular Malaysia" (2026). Research Publications (2026 to 2030). 1361.
https://knova.um.edu.my/research_publications_2026_2030/1361
Funders
Universiti Malaya, Ministry of Higher Education, Malaysia (FRGS/1/2020/TK0/UM/02/19), National Key Research and Development Program of China (2024YFC3013302)
Volume
40
Issue
2
Publisher
Springer Science and Business Media Deutschland GmbH