A comprehensive review of the structural basis for the selectivity of sulfonamide-based inhibitors for carbonic anhydrase isoforms IX and XII over carbonic anhydrase II based on the available high quality crystallographic data
Document Type
Article
Publication Date
3-1-2026
Abstract
Hypoxia in solid tumours induces carbonic anhydrases (CAs) upregulation, notably CA IX and CA XII, to sustain pH homeostasis. While sulfonamide-based zinc binders show high affinity for these targets, achieving the required selectivity versus the ubiquitous CA II remains challenging. Fortunately, the efforts of the community in obtaining experimental structures of ligand-protein complexes have now generated sufficient samples to rationalize isoform preferences. Herein, we provide our detailed structure-annotated meta-analysis of sulfonamide binding across CA II, CA IX, and CA XII that standardizes residue numbering and interaction taxonomy. We examine 130 X-ray cocrystal structures, CA II (47), CA IX (55), and CA XII (28), to quantify Zn–sulfonamide geometry, entrance-zone contacts (Arg60, Thr199/Thr200, His64 π-cation), conserved water mediation, and occupancy/orientation within the 130s subpocket (residues 131/132/135) that provide the best opportunities for delivering selectivity. From these data, we extract concrete, structure-derived design rules: (i) lowering sulfonamide pKa boosts affinity across isoforms but does not confer selectivity; (ii) directing steric/hydrophobic bulk into the 130s subpocket exploits Phe131/Gly132/Val135 (CA II) versus Val131/Asp132/Leu135 (CA IX) versus Ala131/Ser132/Ser135 (CA XII) differences; (iii) favourable entrance-zone interactions, e.g., salt bridging to Arg60 (IX), halogen bonding to Thr199, and occasional His64 π-cation, enhances IX/XII bias; and (iv) compact, highly polar heads without tailored tails tend to default to preferring CA II. This critical synthesis consolidates the dispersed structural evidence into an isoform-resolved map of selectivity-enabling interactions. This provides public access to a very useful tool for CA IX/XII-selective inhibitor design.
Keywords
Hypoxia-inducible factor, Isozyme selectivity, Tumor microenvironment
Publication Title
Archives of Biochemistry and Biophysics
ISSN
0003-9861
DOI
10.1016/j.abb.2025.110682
Recommended Citation
Ahmad, Sarfraz; Mirza, Muhammad Usman; Nazir, Mamoona; Kee, Lee Yean; Abd Rahman, Noorsaadah Binti; Abdullah, Iskandar; and Trant, John F., "A comprehensive review of the structural basis for the selectivity of sulfonamide-based inhibitors for carbonic anhydrase isoforms IX and XII over carbonic anhydrase II based on the available high quality crystallographic data" (2026). Research Publications (2026 to 2030). 1173.
https://knova.um.edu.my/research_publications_2026_2030/1173
Funders
University of Windsor, Amaro Therapeutics, NSERCDiscovery, Universiti Malaya (IIRG003A-2019), Government of Ontario (ER18-14-114), Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (2018-06338 & 2024–04113), Alliance de recherche numérique du Canada (qkh-310)
Volume
777
Publisher
Academic Press Inc.