A clinical comparison of conventional, custom tray, extraoral scanning, and photogrammetry facial recording techniques for maxillofacial prosthesis fabrication

Document Type

Article

Publication Date

3-1-2026

Abstract

Statement of problemThe fabrication of facial prostheses is a complex and time-consuming process, requiring the precise recording of facial defects and surrounding tissues. Conventional techniques often face challenges such as soft-tissue compression, involuntary patient movements, and inadequate support for impression materials, leading to inaccuracies. Emerging 3-dimensional (3D) imaging and scanning technologies, such as photogrammetry, offer potential alternatives, yet their clinical accuracy and reliability remain insufficiently validated.PurposeThe purpose of this clinical study was to compare the accuracy, procedural efficiency, and material use of 4 maxillofacial recording techniques: conventional alginate impressions, custom trays with alginate, extraoral scanning (Revopoint MIRACO 3D Scanner), and photogrammetry (Polycam app) in the fabrication of nasal prostheses.Material and methodsA total of 28 maxillofacial recording specimens were obtained from 7 participants (aged 18 to 24 years) using 4 distinct techniques: conventional alginate impressions (Conv), custom trays with alginate (Cust), extraoral scanning using the Revopoint MIRACO 3D Scanner (Ex-S), and photogrammetry using the Polycam app (Ph-S). Digital maxillofacial casts generated with an intraoral scanner (Primescan; Dentsply Sirona) served as the reference standard. The accuracy of the specimens was assessed using 3D deviation measurements in a software program (Geomagic Control X), and procedural time was recorded using a digital stopwatch. Both outcomes were analyzed using a repeated-measures mixed-effects model, followed by Bonferroni-adjusted pairwise comparisons (α=.05). Material waste was recorded and analyzed descriptively.ResultsThe Ex-S group demonstrated the highest accuracy, with a mean deviation of 54 ±18 µm, followed by the Cust group (85 ±32 µm) and the Ph-S group (87 ±13 µm). The Conv group showed the largest deviation (147 ±56 µm). A repeated-measures mixed-effects model revealed a significant main effect of technique (P< .001). Pairwise comparisons showed that Conv had significantly higher deviations than Ex-S (P=.011). No statistically significant differences were found between Conv and Cust (P=.058), Cust and Ex-S (P=.059), Conv and Ph-S (P=.263), Cust and Ph-S (P>.999), or Ex-S and Ph-S (P=.068). Procedural time also varied significantly among groups. The Conv group recorded the longest time (45.0 ±3.0 minutes), followed by Cust (6.0 ±1.0 minutes), Ex-S (3.6 ±0.5 minutes), and Ph-S (3.0 ±0.5 minutes). Pairwise comparisons indicated that Conv was significantly longer than all other groups (P< .001 for all) and that Cust was significantly longer than both Ex-S (P=.001) and Ph-S (P< .001). No significant difference was observed between Ex-S and Ph-S (P=.180). Material waste was highest in the Conv group (230 ±45 g) and reduced in the Cust group (116 ±18 g). The digital groups Ex-S and Ph-S produced no material waste.ConclusionsDigital recording techniques, particularly extraoral scanning and photogrammetry, provide better accuracy, reduce material waste, and enhance procedural efficiency compared with conventional techniques. Custom trays offer a suitable transitional solution for practitioners moving toward fully digital workflows.

Keywords

Adolescent; Alginates; Dental Impression Technique; Female; Humans; Imaging, Three-Dimensional; Male; Maxillofacial Prosthesis; Photogrammetry; Prosthesis Design; Reproducibility of Results; Young Adult, alginic acid

Publication Title

Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry

ISSN

0022-3913

DOI

10.1016/j.prosdent.2025.05.018

Volume

135

Issue

3

First Page

625

Last Page

631

Publisher

Elsevier Inc.

Share

COinS